Skip to main content
Academy of Public Policy and Economics
Academy of Public Policy and Economics
ISSN 3005-4818 (Online) · Quarterly · Open Access (CC BY 4.0)
Research Articles

Environmental Code Reform, Enterprise Abatement Outlays, and Stationary Industrial Emissions: Subnational Evidence from Kazakhstan, 2010–2025

  1. 1 Institute for Sustainable Development and Innovation
  2. 2 Academy of Public Policy and Economics

Abstract

Staggered industrial environmental codes pair multi-year preparatory monitoring windows with scheduled transitions toward best-available-technique permitting and progressive fee multipliers, raising an open mechanism question: do historically emission-intensive industrial regions adjust during early preparatory compliance through enterprise current abatement outlays and end-of-pipe pollutant capture, or does emission-intensity compression emerge as integrated-permit and fee-escalation thresholds arrive? Assembling a boundary-harmonized panel across all 16 consolidated parent regions of Kazakhstan from 2010 to 2025 (N = 256) around Environmental Code No. 400-VI (enacted January 2021, entering into general force July 2021, with Category I integrated permitting and scheduled fee multipliers commencing January 2025), we estimate exposure-gradient regressions with 9,999 null-imposed wild cluster bootstrap replications. Across 2022–2025, one standard deviation higher predetermined 2017–2019 stationary emission exposure is associated with no statistically resolved change in log real enterprise current environmental protection outlays (+0.0947 log points; clustered SE = 0.0869; bootstrap p = 0.3303) and statistically unresolved shifts in stationary pollutant capture shares (-0.0167; 95% bootstrap set [-0.0773, 0.0293]; p = 0.4876) and log captured tonnage (-0.0284; p = 0.8925). Conversely, relative compression in stationary emission intensity concentrates in the 2025 commencement year (-32.85 tonnes per billion 2020 tenge of real industrial output; SE = 13.37; bootstrap p = 0.0080; inverted 95% bootstrap set [-70.60, -8.91]; six-outcome within-phase Holm p = 0.0480; 24-test Holm p = 0.1920). This 2025 gradient strengthens without contemporaneous output controls (-56.79; bootstrap p = 0.0007) and persists across parent-clustered 17-region panels (-30.47; p = 0.0014), 2014–2016 anchors (-34.35; p = 0.0064), and directionally across all 16 single-region deletions (15 significant at 5%; Pavlodar omission p = 0.0660), while coexisting with pre-2020 downward exposure drift that bounds interpretation to conditional subnational convergence.

Figures Click any figure to enlarge
Figure 1. Dynamic exposure-gradient event studies across enterprise outlays, pollutant capture, and emission intensity.
Figure 2. Subnational exposure scatter, empirical intensity distributions, and regional-group emission shares.
Figure 3. Leave-one-region-out stability, specification diagnostics, and environmental capital-to-current outlay ratios.

Data Availability & Replication

Regional atmospheric emission inventories, enterprise environmental protection expenditure accounts, industrial production series, and statutory texts of the 2021 Environmental Code originate from official publications of the Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan, and the Official Information Resource of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Boundary-harmonized regional datasets, archived statistical inputs, and full replication code are deposited in Zenodo at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24199870.

Replication Archive DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24199870 (2.92 MB, CC BY 4.0)

Declarations

AI declaration
In preparing this article, OpenAI Codex was used solely to support the translation and proofreading of Russian- and Kazakh-language statistical and legal documents, routine data cleaning, and implementation-level verification of the estimation code. All authors independently inspected and verified these auxiliary outputs, completed every other aspect of the research, and assume full responsibility for the final text.
Funding
This research received institutional support from the Institute for Sustainable Development and Innovation (ISDI) and the Academy of Public Policy and Economics (APPE). No external grants were received.
Competing interests
Kuandek Kabulbakhet is affiliated with the Institute for Sustainable Development and Innovation, and Aizada Isakova and Rachel Whitcombe are affiliated with the Academy of Public Policy and Economics, which publishes Central Asia Observation. No external competing interests are declared.
References 37 references
  1. Shapiro, J. S., & Walker, R. (2018). Why is pollution from US manufacturing declining? The roles of environmental regulation, productivity, and trade. American Economic Review, 108(12), 3814-3854. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20151272
  2. Greenstone, M., & Hanna, R. (2014). Environmental regulations, air and water pollution, and infant mortality in India. American Economic Review, 104(10), 3038-3072. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.104.10.3038
  3. Shapiro, J. S., & Walker, R. (2025). Is air pollution regulation too lenient? Evidence from US offset markets. American Economic Review, 115(9), 3058-3080. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20230761
  4. Porter, M. E., & Linde, C. v. d. (1995). Toward a new conception of the environment-competitiveness relationship. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4), 97-118. https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.9.4.97
  5. Gulbrandsen, L. H., Sammut, F., & Wettestad, J. (2017). Emissions trading and policy diffusion: Complex EU ETS emulation in Kazakhstan. Global Environmental Politics, 17(3), 115-133. https://doi.org/10.1162/glep_a_00418
  6. Assanov, D., Zapasnyi, V., & Kerimray, A. (2021). Air quality and industrial emissions in the cities of Kazakhstan. Atmosphere, 12(3), 314. https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos12030314
  7. Wilde, M. (2007). Best available techniques (BAT) and coal-fired power stations: Can the energy gap be plugged without increasing emissions? Journal of Environmental Law, 20(1), 87-114. https://doi.org/10.1093/jel/eqm039
  8. Netalieva, I., Wesseler, J., & Heijman, W. (2005). Health costs caused by oil extraction air emissions and the benefits from abatement: The case of Kazakhstan. Energy Policy, 33(9), 1169-1177. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2003.11.014
  9. Lange, B. (2006). Searching for the best available techniques – Open and closed norms in the implementation of the EU directive on integrated pollution prevention and control. International Journal of Law in Context, 2(1), 67-88. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1744552306001054
  10. Gautier, L. (2022). The role of nonzero conjectural variation in pollution abatement and output in the design of emission taxes. Environment and Development Economics, 27(2), 184-207. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1355770x21000127
  11. Cameron, A. C., Gelbach, J. B., & Miller, D. L. (2008). Bootstrap-based improvements for inference with clustered errors. Review of Economics and Statistics, 90(3), 414-427. https://doi.org/10.1162/rest.90.3.414
  12. MacKinnon, J. G., & Webb, M. D. (2018). The wild bootstrap for few (treated) clusters. The Econometrics Journal, 21(2), 114-135. https://doi.org/10.1111/ectj.12107
  13. MacKinnon, J. G., Nielsen, M. Ø., & Webb, M. D. (2023). Cluster-robust inference: A guide to empirical practice. Journal of Econometrics, 232(2), 272-299. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2022.04.001
  14. Roodman, D., Nielsen, M. Ø., MacKinnon, J. G., & Webb, M. D. (2019). Fast and wild: Bootstrap inference in Stata using boottest. The Stata Journal: Promoting communications on statistics and Stata, 19(1), 4-60. https://doi.org/10.1177/1536867x19830877
  15. de Chaisemartin, C., & D’Haultfœuille, X. (2020). Two-way fixed effects estimators with heterogeneous treatment effects. American Economic Review, 110(9), 2964-2996. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20181169
  16. Andersson, J. J. (2019). Carbon taxes and CO2 emissions: Sweden as a case study. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11(4), 1-30. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20170144
  17. Stavins, R. N. (2020). The future of US carbon-pricing policy. Environmental and Energy Policy and the Economy, 1, 8-64. https://doi.org/10.1086/706792
  18. Borgersen, T. A., & King, R. M. (2016). Industrial structure and jobless growth in transition economies. Post-Communist Economies, 28(4), 520-536. https://doi.org/10.1080/14631377.2016.1237037
  19. Wang, E. Z., & Yang, M. (2022). Green complexity and CO2 emission: Does institutional quality matter? Energy Economics, 110, 106022. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2022.106022
  20. Zhang, W., Zhang, P., & Niu, X. (2024). The impact of SO2 emissions trading scheme on pollution abatement and labor market for industrial enterprises in China. Frontiers in Environmental Science, 11, 1302809. https://doi.org/10.3389/fenvs.2023.1302809
  21. Tu, Z., & Shen, R. (2014). Can China’s industrial SO2 emissions trading pilot scheme reduce pollution abatement costs? Sustainability, 6(11), 7621-7645. https://doi.org/10.3390/su6117621
  22. He, L. Y., & Ou, J. J. (2017). Pollution emissions, environmental policy, and marginal abatement costs. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 14(12), 1509. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph14121509
  23. Damania, D. (1996). Pollution taxes and pollution abatement in an oligopoly supergame. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 30(3), 323-336. https://doi.org/10.1006/jeem.1996.0022
  24. Rikun, A. D. (1992). On modeling incentive systems which utilize pollution charges for pollution abatement. Environmental and Resource Economics, 2(6), 593-604. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00330285
  25. Berman, E., & Bui, L. T. (2001). Environmental regulation and productivity: Evidence from oil refineries. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 83(3), 498-510. https://doi.org/10.1162/00346530152480144
  26. Greenstone, M. (2002). The impacts of environmental regulations on industrial activity: Evidence from the 1970 & 1977 Clean Air Act Amendments and the Census of Manufactures. Journal of Political Economy, 110(6), 1175-1219. https://doi.org/10.1086/342808
  27. Fowlie, M., Holland, S., & Mansur, E. (2012). What do emissions markets deliver and to whom? Evidence from Southern California's NOx trading program. American Economic Review, 102(2), 965-993. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.102.2.965
  28. Walker, R. (2013). The transitional costs of sectoral reallocation: Evidence from the Clean Air Act and the workforce. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 128(4), 1787-1835. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjt022
  29. Levinson, A., & Taylor, M. S. (2008). Unmasking the pollution haven effect. International Economic Review, 49(1), 223-254. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2354.2008.00478.x
  30. Jaffe, A., & Palmer, K. (1997). Environmental regulation and innovation: A panel data study. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 79(4), 610-619. https://doi.org/10.1162/003465397557196
  31. Parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2021). Ekologicheskii kodeks Respubliki Kazakhstan ot 2 yanvarya 2021 goda No. 400-VI ZRK [Environmental Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 2 January 2021 No. 400-VI ZRK]. Official Information Resource of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan. https://www.gov.kz/org/ardfm/documents/details/196656?lang=ru
  32. Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2026). Osnovnye pokazateli okhrany atmosfernogo vozdukha i tekushchie zatraty na okhranu okruzhayushchei sredy po regionam Respubliki Kazakhstan za 2005–2025 gody [Main indicators of atmospheric air protection and enterprise current environmental protection expenditures by region of the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2005–2025]. https://stat.gov.kz/ru/industries/environment/stat-eco/publications/347197/
  33. Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2026). Qazaqstan Respublikasynda negizgi kapitalga salyngan investitsiyalar turaly 2025 zhylgy zhinak [Fixed-capital and environmental protection capital investments in the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2025 annual statistical compendium]. https://stat.gov.kz/industries/businessstatistics/stat-invest/publications/506318/
  34. Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2026). Obem promyshlennogo proizvodstva po regionam Respubliki Kazakhstan i indeksy tsen i deflyatory za 2010–2025 gody [Regional industrial production volumes, sectoral outputs, and national industrial and gross domestic product deflators, 2010–2025]. https://stat.gov.kz/
  35. Holm, S. (1979). A simple sequentially rejective multiple test procedure. Scandinavian Journal of Statistics, 6(2), 65-70.
  36. Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2021). Novyi Ekologicheskii kodeks: kak budut vnedryat nailuchshie dostupnye tekhnologii i povyshat stavki platy za emissii s 2025 goda [The new Environmental Code: Best available techniques implementation and scheduled emission fee multipliers from 2025]. Official Information Resource of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan. https://www.gov.kz/org/ecogeo/press/news/details/156140?lang=ru
  37. Bureau of National Statistics of the Agency for Strategic Planning and Reforms of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2025). Qazaqstan Respublikasynda negizgi kapitalga salyngan investitsiyalar turaly 2024 zhylgy zhinak [Fixed-capital and environmental protection capital investments in the Republic of Kazakhstan, 2024 annual statistical compendium]. https://stat.gov.kz/industries/businessstatistics/stat-invest/publications/305468/