Commentary and Critique is an open-access scholarly publication dedicated to providing a forum for the critical examination of social science research, with a particular focus on public policy and economics, spanning political science, sociology, anthropology, law, education, and history.
Central Asia Observation is a scholarly publication dedicated to Central Asian studies, featuring original research on political, economic, and social affairs, including their subfields and interlinkages, as well as development discourses and practicalities within the Central Asian context.
Open Access Policy: Both journals are published Diamond Open Access under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (CC BY 4.0) by the Academy of Public Policy and Economics, with all submission, peer-review, and article processing charges unconditionally waived.
Equipment-embodied growth theory predicts that reallocating fixed-capital formation from civil structures toward machinery and plant modernization accelerates industrial output, yet high-investment transition regions routinely channel over half of capital outlays into construction-installation works. Assembling regional fixed-capital simplex panels across all 14 regions of Uzbekistan (2000–2025 for technological shares, N = 364; 2007–2025 for reproduction modes, N = 266; 2016–2025 for constant-price industrial value-added growth, N = 140) alongside boundary-harmonized regional benchmarks from Kazakhstan (2003–2026Q3), we evaluate compositional reallocation hypotheses using full-simplex two-way fixed-effects regressions and 9,999 null-imposed wild cluster bootstrap replications. Across all six primary specifications conditioning on real investment scale, real investment growth, employment growth, and residual simplex shares, shifting 10 percentage points from construction-installation works into machinery and equipment yields statistically unresolved contemporaneous (+0.74 percentage points; bootstrap p = 0.7025; 95% bootstrap interval [-1.66, 3.66]) and lagged (+0.56; bootstrap p = 0.3828) industrial growth associations that remain null under predetermined scale controls (+0.63; bootstrap p = 0.3710); a one-year-ahead dynamic association (+1.52; bootstrap p = 0.0319) does not survive six-horizon Holm correction (p = 0.1914), and omitting either Karakalpakstan's 10 region-years (-0.60; bootstrap p = 0.0812) or its single 2016 observation (-0.35; bootstrap p = 0.4017) reverses contemporaneous point estimates negative. On the capital-input margin, reallocating 10 percentage points from greenfield expansion to reconstruction and modernization is associated with a 4.35 percentage-point higher regional machinery share (bootstrap p = 0.0003; 5.75 percentage points with real-scale controls, bootstrap p = 0.0003), while Uzbek-Kazakh subnational comparisons show persistent civil-works dominance whose cross-sectional financing gradients depend on regional consolidation and own-funds scope.
When transition states synchronize corporate registries with automated value-added tax risk scoring, does a steep contraction in active enterprise counts reflect proportional formal-payroll contraction or a two-stage administrative purge of dormant registrations? Combining harmonized district-year panels across 147 boundary-consistent parent jurisdictions covering roughly 84% of national commercial entities and formal payrolls (2016–2025, N = 1,470; payroll window 2017–2024, N = 1,176) with population-matched monthly panels across all 14 regions and nine commercial sectors of Uzbekistan (January 2022–September 2026, N = 7,182), we trace the inactive-enterprise wedge across inter-agency database unification, the January 2023 value-added tax rate cut, and compulsory deregistration. Nationally, commercial inactivity rose from 5.83% at year-end 2022 to 44.86% at year-end 2024 as operating entities fell by 31.38% alongside descriptive national growth in formal workbook employment (+2.95%) and real monthly wages (+14.01%), before receding to 32.06% at year-end 2025 during concentrated register removals. Under region-by-sector and region-by-month fixed effects with exact 14-region wild cluster bootstrap inference, invoice-chain-intensive sectors (industry, construction, and trade) exhibit a 5.56-percentage-point wider inactivity differential during the late-reclassification and deregistration phase (bootstrap p = 0.00012; 95% bootstrap confidence set [4.87, 6.26]), whereas saturating sector-by-month shocks leaves predetermined 2022Q1 regional-sector inactivity and specialization gradients statistically unresolved. Across districts, a 10-percentage-point higher 2019 trade-and-construction share yields conditional 2024 differences of -0.0160 log points in formal employment (bootstrap p = 0.4161; 95% confidence set [-0.0590, 0.0227]; 14-region 80% minimum detectable effect 0.0559) and -0.0281 in real wages (bootstrap p = 0.0908; [-0.0665, 0.0044]), surviving Greater Tashkent transfer restoration and pre-2022 district drift controls.
Staggered industrial environmental codes pair multi-year preparatory monitoring windows with scheduled transitions toward best-available-technique permitting and progressive fee multipliers, raising an open mechanism question: do historically emission-intensive industrial regions adjust during early preparatory compliance through enterprise current abatement outlays and end-of-pipe pollutant capture, or does emission-intensity compression emerge as integrated-permit and fee-escalation thresholds arrive? Assembling a boundary-harmonized panel across all 16 consolidated parent regions of Kazakhstan from 2010 to 2025 (N = 256) around Environmental Code No. 400-VI (enacted January 2021, entering into general force July 2021, with Category I integrated permitting and scheduled fee multipliers commencing January 2025), we estimate exposure-gradient regressions with 9,999 null-imposed wild cluster bootstrap replications. Across 2022–2025, one standard deviation higher predetermined 2017–2019 stationary emission exposure is associated with no statistically resolved change in log real enterprise current environmental protection outlays (+0.0947 log points; clustered SE = 0.0869; bootstrap p = 0.3303) and statistically unresolved shifts in stationary pollutant capture shares (-0.0167; 95% bootstrap set [-0.0773, 0.0293]; p = 0.4876) and log captured tonnage (-0.0284; p = 0.8925). Conversely, relative compression in stationary emission intensity concentrates in the 2025 commencement year (-32.85 tonnes per billion 2020 tenge of real industrial output; SE = 13.37; bootstrap p = 0.0080; inverted 95% bootstrap set [-70.60, -8.91]; six-outcome within-phase Holm p = 0.0480; 24-test Holm p = 0.1920). This 2025 gradient strengthens without contemporaneous output controls (-56.79; bootstrap p = 0.0007) and persists across parent-clustered 17-region panels (-30.47; p = 0.0014), 2014–2016 anchors (-34.35; p = 0.0064), and directionally across all 16 single-region deletions (15 significant at 5%; Pavlodar omission p = 0.0660), while coexisting with pre-2020 downward exposure drift that bounds interpretation to conditional subnational convergence.
Standard user-cost models of housing transmission predict that higher mortgage borrowing rates cool owner-occupied dwelling valuations and residential construction while shifting marginal shelter demand into private rental markets, generating sticky or accelerating rental inflation. We evaluate whether this conditional three-market divergence holds across a balanced quarterly panel of 10 Euro Area economies from 2015Q1 to 2026Q2 (N = 460 country-quarters), co-anchored by 12- and 18-country sensitivity panels, by pairing harmonized bank lending rates for new house purchases with consistently reclassified consumer price indices for actual housing rentals, disaggregated dwelling price indices, and residential building permits. Orthogonal sum-of-squares decomposition across 450 quarterly mortgage-rate transitions shows that common calendar-quarter variation accounts for 80.03% of total variation, leaving 19.19% within-quarter cross-country variation alongside 0.78% persistent country mean differences. Conditional on country and calendar-quarter fixed effects and four lags of domestic macroeconomic and construction-cost states, a 100-basis-point quarterly increase in new mortgage rates is associated over eight quarters (N = 330) with a -12.78 log percentage point cumulative decline in total nominal dwelling prices (enumerated wild cluster bootstrap p = 0.0059; eight-outcome Holm-adjusted p = 0.0469), spanning newly built (-12.81, pointwise p = 0.0078), existing (-11.99, p = 0.0313), and real consumer-price-deflated dwellings (-8.58, p = 0.0488). The conditional joint rental-surge prediction lacks empirical support: eight-quarter nominal actual housing rentals exhibit a pointwise negative slope (-5.30 log percentage points, p = 0.0430, 95% bootstrap interval [-9.49, -0.48]) that softens under Holm multiplicity adjustment (p = 0.2148), lagged demographic controls (p = 0.1328), and 2026Q3 endpoint extension (p = 0.0645), while rentals relative to headline consumer prices remain indistinguishable from zero (-2.60, p = 0.1777). Residential permit contractions are imprecisely estimated in the 10-country construction-cost baseline (-24.89, p = 0.4375) yet reach -21.72 log percentage points at four quarters in an 18-country producer-price panel retaining France, Italy, Belgium, and Ireland (N = 652, p = 0.0281), whereas post-2022 interactions with predetermined 2019–2021 short-fixation mortgage and market-rent tenant shares remain inconclusive under small-sample lag saturation.
When wholesale natural gas and power markets retreat from an acute supply shock, cross-country industrial electricity cost divergence persists as dispersion rotates from traded generation prices toward regulated grid charges and national fiscal wedges. Applying an exact variance–covariance decomposition across all 27 European Union Member States from 2017 to 2025, with semi-annual tax-wedge tracking through the first half of 2026, we document a structural reconfiguration of non-household tariff dispersion across three audited price definitions. In the benchmark medium-scale industrial consumption band (500 to 1,999 MWh annually), the share of cross-country tariff variance attributable to energy and supply costs fell from 57.26% in 2023 to 33.85% in 2025, whereas the regulated network variance share doubled from 6.54% to 13.03% and the net non-recoverable tax variance share reached 22.55%. Across 25 paired Member States in 2025, medium-consumption facilities faced unit network charges 21.85 EUR/MWh above large electro-intensive users alongside an additional 10.98 EUR/MWh net fiscal differential. Combining predetermined 2017–2019 sectoral electricity and gas intensities with a mutually exclusive panel of eight manufacturing divisions across 20 Member States (N = 1,182, 2017–2025) under country-by-sector, country-by-year, and sector-by-year fixed effects, we find a negative conditional association between electricity intensity interacted with regulated network charges and real manufacturing output (-0.00191; wild cluster bootstrap p = 0.0130; Holm family-wise p = 0.0390 across three electricity components), which strengthens on the strictly post-base-period 2020–2025 panel (-0.00283, bootstrap p = 0.0177, N = 783), under a five-country technological benchmark (-0.00259, bootstrap p = 0.0298), and with sector linear trends (-0.00213, bootstrap p = 0.0348), while attenuated first-difference horizons and a negative extended pre-crisis lead (-0.00588, bootstrap p = 0.0290) highlight bidirectional revenue-cap denominator feedback.
When corporate tax statutes defer immediate expensing of intangible investment into multi-year amortization and subsequently restore expensing, user-cost theory predicts a two-sided liquidity pulse concentrated among taxable research-intensive firms. We evaluate this timing-wedge hypothesis across the 2022–2024 mandatory capitalization of research and experimental expenditures under Internal Revenue Code Section 174 and the 2025 domestic expensing restoration under Section 174A. From 4,662 U.S.-incorporated non-financial, non-utility annual corporate filers (40,292 annual periods observed in filings submitted through November 12, 2026), we construct an accounting-corroborated continuous research panel of 586 firms (4,688 firm-years) that eliminates reverse-merger balance-sheet mismatches, alongside an 802-firm date-matched comparison panel. Among firms with positive pre-policy operating income (N = 961, 153 firms, 12 two-digit industries), the conditional slope of net cash income taxes over beginning assets on pre-policy research intensity is +0.0527 during mandatory amortization (SE = 0.0519; restricted wild cluster bootstrap p = 0.2852) and +0.0140 during initial 2025 restoration (SE = 0.0417; bootstrap p = 0.7021), yielding an imprecise reversal contrast of -0.0387 (SE = 0.0357; bootstrap p = 0.2112); omitting a single extreme-hat-value medical-instruments issuer raises the amortization slope to +0.1043 (SE = 0.0219; bootstrap p = 0.0660) and the 2025 slope to +0.0509, while revenue-scaled (+0.1326, bootstrap p = 0.012) and pre-refund gross (+0.1094, bootstrap p = 0.032) cash-tax slopes are positive. Exact unclipped accounting decompositions show that the cash-less-accrued tax wedge widens by +0.1444 in amortization and +0.1575 in 2025 (baseline winsorized slopes +0.1305, bootstrap p = 0.2425, and +0.1329, bootstrap p = 0.0208, or +1.31 and +1.33 percentage points of assets per 10-percentage-point higher research intensity), reflecting positive contemporaneous-income-adjusted cash-tax slopes (+0.0916 and +0.0938) alongside post-2020 earnings mean reversion in book tax accruals, whereas current federal tax expense exhibits a triple-difference reversal contrast of -0.0557 (SE = 0.0194; bootstrap p = 0.020; N = 1,906). Post-2021 research (-0.1682) and capital-expenditure (-0.0324) slopes follow pre-policy upward trends, attenuate under a 2016–2017 exposure anchor (-0.0503, N = 1,216), and show a positive low-cash research interaction (+0.2419, bootstrap p = 0.044), consistent with consolidated jurisdictional aggregation and mid-year enactment timing attenuating observable statutory tax-shield shocks.
Sovereign debt-management models posit an operational trade-off between shortening debt maturity to capture money-like convenience demand in primary auctions and exposing the fiscal balance sheet to faster interest-rate pass-through when policy rates rise. We evaluate both margins across Federal Reserve balance-sheet regimes from January 2015 through October 2026 by linking 4,136 primary-market auctions of U.S. Treasury bills and nominal coupon securities (1,774 unique securities across 142 year-months and 76 fine remaining-maturity tenors) with 142 monthly marketable debt and book interest-rate statements. Conditional on auction month and fine maturity tenor, competitive tenders expand less than proportionally with offering size: during the second quantitative tightening (June 2022–1 December 2025), the log competitive-tender elasticity for Treasury bills is 0.8792 (two-way clustered SE = 0.0314; wild cluster bootstrap p = 0.050 against unit proportionality) and declines to 0.7178 (SE = 0.0386) during post-runoff reserve management from December 2025 onward (regime difference = -0.1614, bootstrap p = 0.005), steepening the bill bid-to-cover slope from -0.4392 (bootstrap p = 0.041) to -0.9237 (bootstrap p = 0.002). Larger offerings during the second quantitative tightening coincide with higher indirect-bidder award shares (+7.0407 percentage points per log offering for bills, bootstrap p = 0.031; +7.5916 percentage points for coupons, bootstrap p = 0.017) and lower primary-dealer residual shares, although wild cluster bootstrap p-values soften above 0.05 under 15-benchmark-family clustering (0.090 and 0.094), without cash management bills (0.113), or outside extraordinary-measures periods (0.085 and 0.633). On the carrying-cost margin, published marketable average interest rates exclude inflation-protected and floating-rate principal and diverge from par-weighted fixed-rate reconstructions by 0.1936 basis points on average (0.8877 basis points maximum) due to net-carrying-value bill discounting. In dynamic monthly models (N = 138), an isolated 100-basis-point federal funds rate hike yields a direct four-lag coefficient sum of 15.10 basis points (HAC SE = 3.11) and, after autoregressive propagation (rho = 0.3507, p = 0.0047), a cumulative four-month impulse response of 22.84 basis points (delta-method HAC SE = 2.66, p < 0.0001; long-run multiplier 23.25 basis points), aligning closely with forward-controlled local projections (24.38 basis points at horizon h = 3). By contrast, the four-month differential for a 10-percentage-point higher bill stock share is statistically inconclusive (+6.72 basis points, HAC SE = 7.11, p = 0.3459; +1.21 basis points, p = 0.8967 under predetermined matched-lag shares), while symmetric shift-share decompositions confirm that 98.3% of direct four-lag policy pass-through operates through within-class rate resets.
Standard floating-rate transmission models predict that monetary tightening depresses corporate capital formation more steeply in economies entering a hiking cycle with elevated non-financial corporate debt-service ratios and reprices shorter-maturity corporate obligations faster than household mortgages. Combining harmonized quarterly institutional sector accounts and Bank for International Settlements sectoral debt-service panels through mid-2026 with an external emerging-market financing benchmark across all 20 regions of Kazakhstan, we evaluate these predictions over the 2022–2025 tightening cycle. Local projections with country and quarter fixed effects and restricted wild cluster bootstrap inference uncover no statistically distinguishable conditional contraction gradient in real non-financial corporate fixed capital formation across 2021Q4 corporate debt-service exposures: at the four-quarter horizon (N = 206 across 16 economies), the interaction per 100-basis-point quarterly policy-rate increase and one-percentage-point initial exposure is -0.0158 log percentage points (country-clustered SE = 0.1127; wild cluster bootstrap p = 0.8732; inverted bootstrap 95% confidence interval [-0.2796, 0.1940]), remaining -0.0189 (bootstrap p = 0.8412) under full-rank Japan-only seasonal indicators, with 80% minimum detectable effects of 2.59 log percentage points per cross-country standard deviation. Evaluated at mean initial exposure, household debt-service ratios rise by 0.7947 percentage points at eight quarters (bootstrap p = 0.0147; 95% bootstrap interval [0.2275, 1.2862]), whereas corporate debt-service (-0.7314, p = 0.6725) and corporate-minus-household gap (-1.5261, p = 0.4103) slopes remain statistically unresolved. In Kazakhstan's external boundary benchmark under 14.25%–18.00% policy rates, enterprise and organization own funds supply 53.17%–55.70% of fixed-capital investment against 4.01%–5.56% from bank loans, exceeding bank credit in all 60 region-period observations.