Skip to main content
Academy of Public Policy and Economics
Academy of Public Policy and Economics
ISSN 3006-6220 (Online) · Quarterly · Open Access (CC BY 4.0)

Editorial Policies

This page sets out the journal’s policies for assessment, publication and the scholarly record.

Peer review

All submissions are first screened by the editorial office for scope, completeness, and adherence to the author guidelines. Manuscripts that pass screening are sent for double-anonymous peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are withheld from each other throughout the process.

Each manuscript is assessed by at least two independent reviewers who hold a doctoral degree, or research standing recognised by the editorial board. Reviewers are asked to comment on the significance of the research question, the soundness of the method and evidence, the treatment of existing literature, and the clarity of presentation, and to recommend acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or rejection.

The handling editor takes the decision on the basis of the reviews. Where reviewers disagree substantively, a third reviewer is invited. Authors receive the full text of reviewer comments with the decision letter. Revised manuscripts are normally returned to the original reviewers.

The journal aims to send a first decision within eight weeks of submission. Accepted articles are published in the current or the next issue. Editors who are authors of a submission take no part in its handling and have no access to the editorial record of that submission.

Reviewer guidelines

Thank you for agreeing to review for this journal. Reviews are expected within three weeks of acceptance of the invitation; if you need longer, tell the editor when you accept.

Before accepting, please confirm that you have no competing interest with the authors or the subject matter, that the manuscript falls within your expertise, and that you can complete the review within the agreed time. Manuscripts sent to you are confidential and may not be shared, circulated to colleagues or students without the editor's agreement, or uploaded to any service that retains submitted text, including generative AI tools.

A useful review addresses the following, with specific reference to the text: whether the research question is clearly stated and worth asking; whether the design, sources, and analytical method can support the claims made; whether the evidence presented is sufficient and correctly interpreted; whether the engagement with existing scholarship is accurate and adequate; whether the argument is followable and the writing clear; and whether the title and abstract represent the content.

Please separate substantive concerns from matters of presentation, and indicate which points you regard as essential to address and which are suggestions. Recommend one of: accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject. Confidential comments to the editor are welcome and are not passed to the authors.

Publication ethics

This journal follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and expects authors, reviewers, and editors to observe the standards set out below.

Authors submit only original work that is not under consideration elsewhere. They present their methods and results accurately, retain the underlying data, and correct the record promptly when an error comes to light. Fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, and the reuse of one's own previously published text or data without acknowledgement are grounds for rejection or retraction. All persons who meet the authorship criteria are named as authors, and no person who does not meet them is included.

Reviewers treat manuscripts as confidential documents, do not use unpublished material for their own purposes, and provide assessments that are specific, evidence-based, and free of personal criticism. They alert the editor to any substantial similarity between the manuscript under review and other published or submitted work.

Editors decide on the basis of scholarly merit and fit with the journal's scope, without regard to the authors' nationality, institution, seniority, gender, or political outlook. They protect the confidentiality of submissions, manage conflicts of interest, and act on credible allegations of misconduct irrespective of when the work was published.

Allegations of misconduct should be sent to [email protected]. The editorial office acknowledges receipt within five working days, informs the corresponding author of the substance of the allegation, and gives an opportunity to respond. Where an allegation is substantiated, the journal issues a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction, and where appropriate informs the authors' institution.

Similarity screening

Editorial screening examines originality, source attribution and overlap with earlier work. Where a similarity report is used, the editor assesses the matched passages in context. Screening results are read by an editor rather than applied as a numerical threshold: overlap in method descriptions or standard terminology is treated differently from overlap in argument, findings, or discussion. Where screening identifies unattributed use of another author's text, data, or figures, the manuscript is returned to the authors with the evidence and an invitation to respond. Substantiated plagiarism results in rejection, and in the case of a published article in retraction. Redundant publication is handled in the same way.

Funding and independence

The journal carries no advertising. The Academy of Public Policy and Economics operates and supports the journal. Institutional support, employment and other relevant relationships must be disclosed; editors must manage conflicts of interest in individual submissions. Where an individual article or a special issue has received external support, that support is declared in the article itself.

The Academy is itself a research institution, and the journals it publishes do not exclude submissions from people connected with it. Researchers engaged by APPE state that affiliation in the submission, as they would any other, and their manuscripts are sent out for anonymous review in the same way as any other submission.

Corrections and retractions

Published articles form part of the scholarly record. Changes to findings, evidence, attribution or other substantive content require a linked correction notice. Minor typographical or layout repairs that do not change the findings, interpretation, attribution or other substantive content may be applied directly to the current article file without a separate notice or a public archive of earlier layouts. Substantive changes must not be presented as layout repairs.

A correction is issued where an error affects a specific element of the article but not its conclusions. The notice states what was wrong, what the correct information is, and whether the error was the author's or the journal's.

An expression of concern is issued where a credible allegation is under investigation, where the investigation will take an extended period, or where the journal has reason to believe that readers should be alerted before a conclusion is reached.

A retraction is issued where the findings are unreliable as a result of error or misconduct, where the work has been published elsewhere without disclosure, where material has been used without permission, or where the peer review process has been compromised. The article remains online, marked as retracted, with the notice giving the reason and stating who requested the retraction.

Readers may report a suspected error to [email protected]. The editorial office responds within ten working days with its assessment and the action it proposes to take.

Complaints and appeals

An author who believes a decision rests on a factual error, a misunderstanding of the manuscript, or a procedural failure may appeal once. Appeals go to [email protected], must be made within thirty days of the decision, and must set out the specific points at issue with reference to the reviews.

The editor who took the decision does not rule on the appeal. Where an appeal raises a substantive point, the manuscript may be sent to a further reviewer; where it does not, the original decision stands. Appeals are answered within twenty working days. Dissatisfaction with an editorial judgement about scope, priority, or significance is not in itself a ground for appeal.

Complaints about the conduct of the editorial process, about a member of the editorial team, or about the journal's handling of an ethical matter should be addressed to the publisher at [email protected], marked for the attention of the publisher rather than the editor.

Indexing and archivingIdentifiers and discovery

The journal registers DOIs with Crossref under prefix 10.62432. Article metadata is available through the OAI-PMH interface for libraries and discovery services.

Access and archiving

Published articles and PDFs are available in the journal archive. Readers may download articles and deposit copies in repositories under the licence stated on each article. For preservation enquiries, contact [email protected].